Table of Contents
Foreword by Scott Veale
Preface
Introduction
1.1 Video Game Review/Grand Theft Auto IV -- Grand Theft Auto Takes On New York
Seth Schiesel
1.2 Art/As Seen on Television: Sealed With a Simpson
Roberta Smith
Part I - Opinion: Critical Essays and Reviews
1. The keys to quality criticism
1.1 Books of the Times -- First Time for Taxis, Lo Mein and Loss
Michiko Kakutani
StoryScan
2. Popular music
2.1 Bob Dylan: A Distinctive Folk-Song Stylist: 20-year old Singer Is Bright New Face at Gerde’s Club
Robert Shelton
2.2 The Rap Against Rockism
Kelefa Sanneth
2.3 Pop: The Sugar Hill Gang
Robert Palmer
2.4 Pop Review – Pop Review; Suburban Listlessness As Caught by Green Day
Jon Pareles
2.5 Critic’s Notebook – Critic’s Notebook; Pop Godmothers, Burnished by Experience
Ann Powers
2. 6 Three Faces of New York Rock: New York Rock
John Rockwell
2.7 Critic’s Choice -- New CDs: Cassandra Wilson “Loverly”
Ben Ratliff, Nate Chinen and Jon Caramanica
2.8 Music -- Songs from the Heart of a Marketing Plan
Jon Pareles
A conversation with . . . Jon Pareles
MakingConnections
3. Classical music, opera and dance
3.1 Connections -- Classical Music Imperiled: Can You Hear the Shrug?
Edward Rothstein
3.2 Music Review/‘Satyagraha’ -- Fanciful Visions on the Mahatma’s Road to Truth and Simplicity
Anthony Tommasini
3.3 Music: Stravinsky, a Rare Bird Amid the Palms; A Composer in California, At Ease if Not at Home
Bernard Holland
3.4 Dance Review -- What Audiences Haven’t Seen Before
Alastair Macaulay
3.5 Dance Review/Los Vivancos -- They Are Men, Hear Them Roar (and Stomp, Tap, Break Dance and Pirouette)
Alastair Macaulay
3.6 Tenor of the Times
David Hajdu
3.7 Music -- In Charting Its Future, City Opera Chooses an Adventurous Path
Anthony Tommasini
3.8 Mining Pop for Avant-Garde Inspiration
Allan Kozinn
MakingConnections
4. Visual arts
4.1 Art -- In the Gloom, Seeing Rembrandt With New Eyes
Holland Cotter
4.2 Art Review – Art Review; In Joyous Colors, a Hint of Joys Lost
Michael Kimmelman
4.3 Art Review/William Eggleston -- Old South Meets New, in Living Color
Holland Cotter
4.4 Big but Not So Bold; Trade Center Towers Are Tallest, But Architecture Is Smaller Scale Ada Louise Huxtable
4.5 An Appraisal -- A Tower of Impregnability, The Sort Politicians Love
Nicolai Ouroussoff
4.6 Art Review/Roy Lichtenstein -- The Painter Who Adored Women
Roberta Smith
4.7 Public Art, Eyesore to Eye Candy
Roberta Smith
A conversation with . . . Roberta Smith
MakingConnections
5. Theater
5.1 Waiting for Godot
Brooks Atkinson
5.2 Theater Review/'Waiting for Godot' -- Tramps for Eternity
Ben Brantley
5.3 West Side Story
Brooks Atkinson
5.4 ‘Utopia’ Is a Bore. There, I Said It
Charles Isherwood
5.5 Stage: ‘Dreamgirls,’ Michael Bennet’s New Musical, Opens
Frank Rich
5.6 Stage: ‘Moose Murders,’ A Brand of Whodunit
Frank Rich
5.7 Theater: ‘Private Lives,’ Burton and Miss Taylor
Frank Rich
5.8 Again, for the First Time
Ben Brantley
A conversation with . . . Ben Brantley
MakingConnections
6. Film
6.1 Defending Goliath: Hollywood and the Art of the Blockbuster
Manohla Dargis
6.2 Film Review – Film Review; The Sorcerer’s Apprentice
Elvis Mitchell
6.3 Movie Review/’Star Wars’ -- A Trip to a Far Galaxy That's Fun and Funny
Vincent Canby
6.4 The Godfather
Vincent Canby
6.5 Orson Welles’s Controversial ‘Citizen Kane’ Proves a Sensational Film at Palace — “That Uncertain Feeling’ at Music Hall — ‘Great American Broadcast’ at Roxy
Bosley Crowther
6.6 Bonnie and Clyde
Bosley Crowther
6.7 Film – Film; You Won’t See My Detroit in the Movies
Elvis Mitchell
6.8 Review/Film; On the Run with 2 Buddies And a Gun
Janet Maslin
6.9 Film View -- Film View; Lay Off ‘Thelma and Louise’
Janet Maslin
6.10 He Found a Bundle of Money, and Now There’s Hell to Pay
A. O. Scott
StoryScan
6.11 Critic’s Notebook -- Avast, Me Critics! Ye Kill the Fun: Critics and the Masses Disagree about Film Choices
A. O. Scott
A conversation with . . . A.O. Scott
MakingConnections
7. Television
7.1 In the ‘24’ World, Family Is the Main Casualty
Ginia Bellafante
7.2 The TV Watch -- Not Speaking for Obama, Pastor Speaks for Himself, at Length
Alessandra Stanley
7.3 The TV Watch -- Gross Out and Knockoff, but Hardly Any Sendup
Alessandra Stanley
7.4 TV Review/ ‘The Morning Show with Mike and Juliet,’ -- ‘We’re not Dating’: A Morning Show With Sex on the Brain
Virginia Heffernan
7.5 Addicted to a Mob Family Potion
Caryn James
7.6 Reporter’s Notebook -- American Idolatry: If Only Reality Were This Well Organized
Edward Wyatt
7.7 Elvis Presley: Lack of Responsibility Is Shown by TV in Exploring Teen-Agers
Jack Gould
MakingConnections
8. Books
8.1 Books of the Times -- Beloved, by Toni Morrison
Michiko Kakutani
8.2 Essay -- In Search of the Best
A. O. Scott
8.3 Essay -- Beyond Criticism
Sam Tanenhaus
8.4 Books of the Times -- Post 9/11, a New York of Gatsby-Size Dreams and Loss
Michiko Kakutani
8.5 Books of the Times -- A Pynchonesque Turn by Pynchon
Michiko Kakutani
8.6 Books of the Times -- Lolita by Vladimir Nabokov
Orville Prescott
8.7 Aw, the World’s a Crumby Place
James Stern
8.8 Books of the Times -- Story of an Unfinished Story
Christopher Lehmann-Haupt
8.9 Not Funnies
Charles McGrath
8.10 Critic’s Notebook -- Bending the Truth in a Million Little Ways
Michiko Kakutani
8.11 Books of the Times -- Unraveling the Labyrinthine Life of a Magical Realist
Janet Maslin
8.12 Books of the Times/’One Shot’ -- Action Hero Travels Light and Often Takes the Bus
Janet Maslin
A conversation with . . . Janet Maslin
MakingConnections
Part II - Reportage - Profiles and Trend Pieces
9. Profiles
9.1 The Music Man
Lynn Hirschberg
9.2 A Higher Calling
Lynn Hirschberg
9.3 At the Met With: Cindy Sherman; Portraitist In the Halls Of Her Artistic Ancestors
Michael Kimmelman
9.4 Music; Down From the Mountain, Singing With More Serenity
Ann Powers
StoryScan
9.5 Myths, Dreams, Realities–Sam Shepard’s America
Michiko Kakutani
9.6 Television – Television; How Does Seinfeld Define Comedy? Reluctantly
Glenn Collins
9.7 Film -- Mike Nichols, Master of Invisibility
Charles McGarth
9.8 Yale Senior, A Vietnam Memorial and a Few Ironies
B. Drummond Ayres Jr.
MakingConnections
10. Trend Pieces
10.1 Are Book Reviewers Out of Print?
Motoko Rich
10.2 Radiohead to Let Fans Decide What to Pay for Its New Album
Jeff Leeds
10.3 The Media Equation -- Live Music Thrives as CDs Fade
David Carr
10.4 Will Theater in Los Angeles Fade to White?
Margo Jefferson
10.5 When Reality TV Gets Too Real
Jeremy W. Peters
10.6 How Inner Torment Feeds the Creative Spirit
Samuel G. Freedman
MakingConnections
Epilogue: How publication in The New York Times changed my career
Three-Chord Music in a Three-Piece Suit
Don McLeese
StoryScan